But They May Have Unique Therapeutic Potential
Scientists have succeeded in isolating human testes stem cells that resemble embryonic stem cells in that they can differentiate into each of the three main types of tissues of the body.
But the researchers caution against viewing them as one and the same.
According to the study, the testes stem cells have different patterns of gene expression and regulation and they do not proliferate and differentiate as aggressively as human embryonic stem cells.
The findings by researchers at the Stanford University School of Medicine and at UC-San Francisco differ from those reported in a recent Nature paper that concluded that the cells were as pluripotent as embryonic stem cells.
Pluripotent cells can become any cell in the body and form tumors called teratomas when transplanted into mice.
“It’s time to reinterpret the data,” said Renee Reijo-Pera, PhD, professor of obstetrics and gynecology at Stanford, “and to accept that we’re beginning to discover many different types of stem cells. Although they are all related to each other, they also all have unique therapeutic applications in which they surpass other family members.”
Reijo-Pera, who is the director of Stanford’s Center for Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research and Education, collaborated with male infertility specialist Paul Turek, MD, a professor of urology at UCSF and the director of The Turek Clinic in San Francisco, to conduct the research.
The stem cells from the testes seem to hover in a gray area between true pluripotency and the more limited, tissue-specific multipotency exhibited by many types of adult stem cells.
They termed the cells “multipotent germline stem cells.”
Germ cells are those cells in the body that differentiate to make sperm and eggs.
Playing to these cells’ strengths, such as their likely ability to differentiate into cells involved in male reproduction, may be a wiser choice than trying to pigeonhole them as embryonic-stem-cell-wannabes, Reijo-Pera said.
“These cells could potentially treat infertility or other diseases in men,” Turek said.
But the lure of pluripotency is strong.
An easily accessible source of unmodified, pluripotent human cells would allow physicians and researchers to create cell lines and tissues identical to others in the donor’s body.
Theoretically such cells could be used as a perfectly matched therapy for that particular donor, perhaps to generate new cartilage to repair a knee injury or new neurons to treat nerve damage.
Alternatively, the technique could be used to derive cell lines carrying specific disease-causing mutations from a man with Parkinson’s, for example, on which to conduct research.
Coaxing specialized, or differentiated, adult cells to regress back into a more malleable, embryonic-stem-cell-like state, a process called “induced pluripotency,” would also allow scientists to realize the therapeutic benefits of embryonic cells without the thorny ethical problems that plague cells derived from embryos.
Until recently, however, the reprogramming of differentiated cells required the use of viruses to introduce specific genes into the cells, which may limit their therapeutic usefulness.
The researchers used cells obtained via biopsies conducted to diagnose male infertility in 19 of the clinic’s patients.
Each patient’s cells were cultured in a manner similar to human embryonic stem cells; two of the 19 samples yielded cell lines with many characteristics of the pluripotent cells.
One of the two patients from whom the cell lines were derived withdrew from the study and his samples were discarded.
Further study on the remaining cell line indicated that it expressed many, but not all, genes associated with pluripotency.
The cells could also be induced to differentiate into decidedly non-testicular neural cell precursors and they expressed the telomerase enzyme essential to keep pluripotent cells young and unspecialized.
However, when the researchers examined the cells’ patterns of methylation, which is a modification to DNA that affects gene expression, they found that the newly derived cell line was less-thoroughly methylated as compared to human embryonic stem cells in one region and more heavily methylated than human embryonic stem cells in another region.
Finally, when the researchers injected the human stem cells into mice with compromised immune systems, they showed only a limited ability to form a kind of tumor known as a teratoma that formed of many cell types.
Teratoma formation resulting from the aggressive proliferation and differentiation of transplanted stem cells is a hallmark of true pluripotency.
Together, the results suggest that the stem cells isolated from male testes have some, but not all the characteristics of true pluripotent cells.
“It’s not yet possible to completely re-create human embryonic stem cells from germline cells,” Reijo-Pera said. “These cells differ in gene expression, methylation and in their ability to form teratomas. But it’s the fact that they are different that makes them so interesting. Suggesting otherwise would do a disservice to the research community by overlooking the fact that these cells are a unique cell type that could be really useful in the study of human germ cell formation.”
The study was published in the January issue of the journal Stem Cells. Reijo-Pera and Turek are co-senior authors of the study.
The Turek Clinic is a medical practice specializing in issues facing men of reproductive age.
Contact: Renee Reijo-Pera, email@example.com